Today I would like to touch one of the most complex topics in aquarium hobby – Allelopathy in aquarium plants.
Allelopathy is a natural phenomenon, which is often defined as: The inhibition of growth in one species of aquatic plants or algae by chemicals produced by another species.
I believe that many aquarists have experienced the effect of this warfare between plants in their tanks without even realizing it. I am talking about situations when some hobbyists simply cannot grow this or that aquarium plants although their tanks have almost ideal requirements and water parameters for them.
Why some species of aquarium plants keep dying in some of our planted tanks but thrive in others?
Allelopathy might be the answer. Although in recent years, research on the allelopathy of algae and water plants has gradually increased, we still do not have full information to be absolutely certain how it works.
What is Allelopathy?
The word allelopathy is derived from two separate Greek words, Allelon which means “Of each other”, and pathos which means “to suffer”.
Although the theory of allelopathy was described at the beginning of the 20th century by the Austrian professor Hans Molisch, scientists could not find enough empirical evidence of these interactions until 1966.
By that time the International Allelopathy Society (IAS) defined this phenomenon as any process involving secondary metabolites produced by plants, algae, bacteria, and fungi that influences the growth and development of biological systems.
Basically, allelopathy occurs when any organism produces chemicals that affect another organism. It means that not only your plants in the tank has this ability, the algae in the tank can also use it against the plants and even against another algae species as well!
- Aquatic plants vs aquatic plants,
- Aquatic plants vs algae,
- Algae vs algae.
This means that allelopathic chemicals target and inhibit organisms indiscriminately. It prevents the organisms from growing or spreading at a normal rate. This inhibition may also ultimately kill the target organism.
Allelopathy is natural warfare of the plants and algae in the aquarium. This is the ultimate adaptive strategy in their competition for light and nutrients.
Note: Every plant species is different. Therefore, in spite of the fact that allelopathy commonly inhibits other organisms, this effect can be also positive for some species.
Other Reasons for Allelopathy in Aquatic Plants
Now we know that in general allelopathic chemicals help plants establish dominance in a tank. This is because of how the chemicals inhibit the growth of other plants. A single allelochemical may not be a strong inhibitor by itself.
So, plants may use and combine two or more allelochemicals, you can expect to see an increase in the power of the inhibition effect. Allelopathic chemicals may also affect different organisms differently. Some organisms may be inhibited more by specific allelopathic chemicals.
However, allelopathy is not limited to just fight other plants or algae in the tanks. Some aquarium plants use these chemicals function as a defense mechanism to protect against insects, snails, fish from being eaten.
Ideally, it is always good to research what plants and aquatic animals are not compatible with each other when you are making a planted tank.
Interesting fact: Allelopathic chemicals are not used in the growth and development process of plants. The sole role of the chemicals is to work as an active defense mechanism in plants, and algae.
You can read more about it in the articles:
Why Are Allelochemicals More Common in Aquarium Plants?
Allelochemicals are most often seen being produced in aquarium plants. This is because plants are at risk of being eaten by herbivores. Some plants produce allelochemicals as a natural defense to predators. These chemicals can prevent aquarium plants from being eaten.
Producing allelochemicals does require plants to use some energy. It takes around 10% or slightly less metabolic investment in order to produce allelochemicals.
This may sound like a lot for a defense mechanism. However, allelochemicals are an effective way to prevent plant losses caused by herbivore grazers. The chemicals can also protect aquarium plants from disease.
How Does Allelopathy Inhibit Aquarium Plants?
Allelochemicals are released directly from plants through different mechanisms, such as root secretion, leaching, volatilization, and also passively through plant decomposition.
Allelopathy can affect the root systems of plants. The chemicals can cause the roots to be unable to absorb nutrients normally. The chemicals can also cause the process of obtaining water to be much more stressful on the plant.
Allelopathy can cause water stress when the roots of a plant have been affected by allelopathic chemicals for longer periods of time. In addition, allelopathic chemicals can also affect protein biosynthesis. A plant struggling to undergo protein biosynthesis will have their cell growth affected as well.
Allelopathic chemicals can also affect normal plant processes like photosynthesis and respiration.
The chemicals can make it so that the parts that help the plant undergo photosynthesis don’t develop correctly. Allelopathic chemicals can also encourage faster decomposition of photosynthetic pigments, affect the respiration process, and affect enzymes.
What Aquatic Plants Use Allelopathy?
20 years ago Diana Walstad wrote a book and created her own way (the Walstad Method) of growing plants in the planted tank.
|Ecology of the Planted Aquarium:
A Practical Manual and Scientific Treatise for the Home Aquarist – link to check the price on Amazon
In her book, she mentions that there are at least 97 aquatic plants that have been reported to use allelopathy.
Due to the fact that the use of allelopathy is a more recent discovery. It is very possible that all/most aquatic plants secrete some sort of chemicals that affect other organisms. However, this has not been proven by researchers as of right now.
Some common aquarium plants like Duckweed, Vallisneria, Hornwort, Sagittaria, Bacopa, Pistia stratiotes, Cabomba, Ludwigia hexapetala, etc. have all been tested and proven to produce allelochemicals. It may be very useful to know if we start having problems with other plants in our tanks without any obvious reason.
For example, according to the study, Pistia stratiotes was responsible for the reduction in the germination of 80 % observed on crop growth. Scientists found several allelopathic compounds (such as α-asarone, hydroxyl fatty acids, and steroid derivatives) which inhibited the growth of 17 algal cultures. At the same time, rice was the most tolerant to allelopathic effects.
In another experiment, Sagittaria sagittafolia inhibited the germination of wheat and wild oat but enhanced milk thistle.
Once again it shows us that all plants react differently to these effects. In some cases, they will not even notice it or they may even use it beneficially for their own growth.
How Have Aquatic Plants Evolved to Use Allelopathy?
To understand allelopathy in aquatic plants, we have to look at the structures of the plants that live on land. Land plants use phenolics in order to synthesize lignins.
Lignins help land plants to stand upright. They are essential for land plants but aquatic plants use water buoyancy in order to provide structural support. Lignins are still created but in much smaller amounts. So, what happens to the excess phenolics that are normally used to produce lignins for structural support?
The answer is that the phenolics are used during the process of allelopathy.
Plants did not need to undergo extreme changes in order to develop the ability to use allelopathy. From the start, phenolics naturally worked as inhibitors for plants. This means that aquatic plants did not need to develop whole new systems in order for allelopathy to happen.
The plants just had to make slight adjustments in the ways that they used phenolics. Over time, phenolics evolved through genetic mutations. This has caused them to be more effective at inhibiting other organisms.
The phenolics now have stronger inhibiting properties than in the past. Slightly altering common phenolic acids can result in inhibition in algae.
How Do Different Amounts of Phenolic Acids Affect Organisms?
The inhibiting process of organisms during allelopathy is due to phenolic acids that plants create. It is only natural that plants that have higher concentrations of phenolic acids are less likely to be eaten. A plant becomes indigestible when the plant contains more than 6% of phenolic acids. This allows the plant to naturally be able to protect itself against herbivores.
Phenolic acid levels can range. Some plants, like the Elodea Densa, may contain concentrations of phenolic acids as low as 0.8%. Other plants, like the Cabomba Caroliniana, can contain concentrations of phenolic acids as high as 15%. These plants would be considered to be indigestible due to the high phenolic acid content.
How Does Allelopathy Repel Insects or Fish?
Phenolics, which are produced for the allelopathy process, deactivate proteins. Phenolics can damage the proteins in an animal or an insect’s stomach. This is a natural deterrence to anyone who may want to snack on the plant.
What Are Some Potential Usages of Allelopathy in Aquarium Hobby?
Helpful Usages Concerning Aquatic Plants
Allelopathy in aquariums allows certain plants to thrive. Plant growth is normally directly linked to algae growth. In healthy planted aquariums, you can expect to see lower levels of algae. In aquariums where plants are struggling, you can expect to see higher levels of algae.
By keeping your plants healthy, you can control algae growth in an aquarium. Algae blooms can have a high impact on aquatic environments. This is because some species of algae or cyanobacteria (for example, “blue-green algae”) actually produce toxins.
A high concentration of these toxins may affect fish currently residing in your tank. You can also decrease the amount of algae in a tank by decreasing the amount of light that your tank gets on a daily basis.
What is Auto-Inhibition in Aquarium Plants?
Auto-inhibition occurs when a plant makes allelochemicals that inhibit its own species.
Auto-inhibition sounds extremely self-destructive. Why would a species want to slow the growth and prevent new growths of its own species?
The answer is that auto-inhibition is actually helpful in some situations. Some tank environments may not be suitable for a large amount of plants. This causes new plants to compete for resources with existing plants.
Competing with your own species can be just as harmful as competing with non-related species for resources.
By limiting the growth of their own species, these auto-inhibiting plants make it so that the adult plants of their species can thrive more. At the same time, the younger plants are not likely to survive.
This means that new plants aren’t growing in to replace the older plants. Some species of algae naturally display auto-inhibiting traits.
We used to think that the aquarium hobby is a source of relaxation and serenity. Recent studies show, however, that this may not be true for the plants inside.
Allelopathy or never-ending warfare between plants in our tanks is a real thing!
In nature, it is not possible to find so many plant species in such limited space as our tanks. That is why in our aquariums, all plants face severe competition for resources, either space, light, or nutrients.
As a result, we often do not even realize what actually is happening in our planted tanks.
- Ecology of the Planted Aquarium: A Practical Manual and Scientific Treatise for the Home Aquarist. Diana Walstad. 1999.
- Allelopathic Effect of Lotus and Arrowhead Weed on Wheat, Wild Oat and Milkthistle Germination. Planta Daninha. May 2019. DOI: 10.1590/s0100-83582019370100031.
- Allelopathy of Aquatic Autotrophs. First publ. in: Critical Reviews in Plant Science 22 (2003), pp. 313-339.
- Allelopathic activity of Ceratophyllum demersum L. and Najas marina ssp. intermedia (Wolfgang) Casper. First publ. in: Hydrobiologia 506 (2003), pp. 583-589.
- Thiébaut G, Thouvenot L and Rodríguez-Pérez H (2018) Allelopathic Effect of the Invasive Ludwigia hexapetala on Growth of Three Macrophyte Species. Front. Plant Sci. 9:1835. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2018.01835.
- Allelopathy; A brief review. Jordan Journal of Applied Science. January 2020.
- Effect of allelopathy on plant performance. Preprint. May 2020. DOI: 10.1101/2020.05.14.095190.
- A review of allelopathy on microalgae. Microbiology 2019; 165:587–592. DOI 10.1099/mic.0.000776.
- Allelopathic effect of the aquatic macrophyte, Stratiotes aloides, on natural phytoplankton. Freshwater Biology (2006) 51, 554–561. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2427.2006.01510.x.
- Allelopathic Effects of Pistia stratiotes (Araceae) and Lyngbya wollei Farlow ex Gomont (Oscillariaceae) on Seed Germination and Root Growth. Sustainable Agriculture Research. October 2014. DOI: 10.5539/sar.v3n4p121.