Culling shrimp is the process of removing or segregating shrimp from a breeding stock based on a specific trait. This is done to improve and exaggerate desirable characteristics or to remove and decrease undesirable characteristics. Some people do not like the word culling and use Selective breeding instead, which is basically the same. A lot of times when shrimp breeders are culling, they are selecting towards the standard either their own or written.
Culling shrimp, in contrast to mere breeding shrimp, defines controlled reproduction with a specific breeding goal. A culling goal is usually a certain phenotypic characteristic expression. Therefore, selective breeding is a method to achieve this goal.
However, in order to understand better how culling shrimp (selective breeding) works we need to remember school biology lessons first.
Gregor Mendel’s Rules of Inheritance
Gregor Mendel (1822 – 1884) was an Austrian monk and biologist who loved to work with plants by breeding the pea plants. He discovered the principles that rule heredity. Mendel combined a purebred yellow-seeded plant with a purebred green-seeded plant and he got only yellow seeds.
He called the yellow color trait the Dominant one because it was expressed in all the new seeds. Then he let the new yellow seeded hybrid plants self-fertilize and in this second generation, he got both yellow and green seeds which meant that the green trait had been hidden by the dominant yellow. He called this hidden trait the Recessive trait.
For example, Crystal Red shrimp and Crystal Black shrimp. The black color is dominant and the red color is Recessive.
Mendel did not know about genes, but he did speculate that there were 2 factors for each basic trait and that 1 factor was inherited from each parent. Now we know that these factors are called Alleles and represent the different variations of a gene.
Phenotype – the visible or observable expression of the results of genes, combined with the environmental influence on an organism’s appearance or behavior. It is what you can see.
Genotype is the information within a gene. Genotypes can only be determined by biological tests, not observations. It is the information contained within two alleles.
Types of Shrimp Selection
There are three types of Natural selection and two types of Artificial selection (Culling).
Natural selection of shrimp includes :
- Stabilizing. Individuals with the average form of the trait have the highest fitness. For example, imagine berried Cherry shrimp females with 5 eggs or 100 eggs. Both variants are not optimal in the wild. In the first case, the number of shrimplets is not enough to increase the population (because of predators). In the second case, the number is just too high. As a result, the competition for food will weaken all shrimp in the colony and they can die. Therefore, 20-50 eggs are optimal.
- Disruptive. Individuals with either extreme variation of a trait have greater fitness than individuals with an average form of the trait. For example, large females produce more shrimplets, and small males are more agile and have more chances to fertilize the eggs.
- Directional. Individuals that display a more extreme form of a trait have greater fitness than individuals with an average form of the trait. For example, if we look at wild types of Neocaridina shrimp we will see that they have brown coloring with light patches. The explanation is simple those shrimp that can hide from predators the most effectively will live the longest. That is why it is not possible to see red or yellow colors in the wild. Shrimp with bright colors will shine like a beacon for any predator.
Artificial selection of shrimp includes:
Inbreeding is the mating of closely related (genetically) shrimp. It is intentionally practiced to create the genetic uniformity of the shrimp. Inbreeding is generated by keeping small populations of shrimp during selection (for example, it is said that Crystal red shrimp strain was created from only 3 shrimp, making it extremely inbred and sensitive).
The downside of this method is that with every new shrimp generation they can start losing their coloration. It is called traits depression. However, this is not the only bad news. Moderate to high levels of inbreeding (> 10%) can:
- decrease shrimp fertility or eggs loss,
- decrease survival rate,
- reduce a life span,
- increase the frequency of mutations and physical deformities,
- make shrimp more susceptible to diseases and environmental stresses. Especially when shrimp are reared under stressful conditions.
- cause the loss of genetic diversity.
The only way to fix this problem is to introduce “new blood” to the colony from time to time. New batches of shrimp will refresh the genetic pool and will make it more stable and stronger. Sometimes biologists also call it Interbreeding (genetically unrelated members of the same species).
What is Shrimp Linebreeding?
Linebreeding is a term usually used to describe milder forms of inbreeding. Typically it involves arranging matings so that one or more relatives occur more than once in a line while avoiding close inbreeding.
Crossbreeding (outbreeding) is the mating of two shrimp, who not only are the products of two distinctly separate lines but on top are not the products of linebreeding. In most cases, shrimp breeders use this term to describe the mating between two different species of shrimp.
What is a Mischling Shrimp?
Mischling is a German word for “crossbreed” shrimp.
Do We Need Culling?
If you want to keep your shrimp colony looking as best as it can, well, actually, you do not have a choice. You will need to cull shrimp. Culling them will make your shrimp colony have better colorations and patterns. Otherwise, they will revert to a wild-type color. Therefore, the more you cull the more high-grade shrimp you will have in the tank.
You can read more about “How to Enhance Shrimp Color?” right here.
- In order of priority. The obvious choice would be to remove deformities first, then color, then pattern. For example, you can have a good pattern Crystal red shrimp with a really bad color. Color is one of those things that is much harder to breed.
- Keep in mind that shrimp color develops with age. They get stronger colorations as they get older. By the time they are breeding age, they should be around full coloration. Wait until baby shrimp are one centimeter at least. You do not want to cull too early. Shrimp can improve a lot, especially right before maturity. It is a fine line between not culling too early and not waiting too long.
- Remember that molting affects color. It takes shrimp a few days to restore their color after molting.
- Male shrimp usually do not have vibrant colors compared to females. Pay attention to that or you will not have any males left in the tank. You can read more about “Shrimp Gender. Female and Male Difference” right here.
- If you do not have a Culling tank, try to keep a good ratio of males and females. However, it can be also a problem because the key is to try to get rid of the bad males. The point is that males are the ones that give the dominant colors and patterns.
- If you have the culling tank, it is better to keep a few really good males into a colony and remove all the rest. In this case, the gender ratio will not be that important, just leave females in the culling tank until they are berried.
- There is no point in culling when you only have a few shrimp. Unless you want to start the project from scratch. 10-15 shrimp is a good number to start.
- The rule for selection should get more and more strict over time. For example, if you start from 20 to 50 to 100, then back to 20. Nonetheless, do not be overzealous.
How Often Should We Cull The Shrimp?
The more you do it the better is the result. Ideally, at least once a week or two. If you do not make a selection according to the brightness of the color, then in about 10 generations, the shrimp will lose most of their color.
How to Catch the Shrimp for Culling
If you have a big colony in a planted tank, it is very easy to miss undesirable shrimp. Therefore, stop feeding them for 2-3 days before culling. After that, when you put some food into feeding plates they would all come out into the open in 15-30 minutes. However, if you think that there are still more unwanted shrimp in the tank, remove the food and repeat the process the next day. At that point, you are most likely going to catch the majority of the shrimp. At least to the best of your ability.
Take a net and basically just scoop the shrimp out. Hold the net against the glass because quite often they can jump away. However, if you have a lot of plants in there or a lot of decorations, which you do not want to disturb then you can make a shrimp trap.
What to do with the culls?
There comes a time in every shrimp keeper’s life when they have to decide the shrimp’s fate. Although shrimp have very little awareness about what is happening to them, a lot of people still ask this question because they feel responsible for their shrimp lives after all. I will try to name the most popular, quick, and painless ways.
- Separate tank for mischlings. Let them go wild and breed to the heart’s content. Actually, you may get some good ones out of it once in a while.
- Throw them in a fish or turtle tank. They may live or die very quickly.
- Sell them for a little profit to other shrimp keepers, who just do not really care about grade or type.
- Put them in boiling water. Relatively painless and quick.
- Put shrimp into a freezer.
- Squashing it.
- Give them away to other hobbyists.
About Shrimp Crossbreeding charts
Well, to tell the truth, all these charts are almost useless. Anybody who has been in shrimp hobby even for some time knows that Neocaridina species can crossbreed, and the same is with Caridina species (except Amano shrimp, Malawa shrimp, Red Nose Shrimp, and some others).
The good news is that shrimp with different genera will not crossbreed and can be safely housed together.
The bad news is that we do not always know the species or even the genus of the shrimp! Therefore, with so many unknowns, it is very difficult to make a definitive chart of what can and cannot crossbreed.
You can read more about “The Difference between Neocaridina and Caridina Shrimp” right here.
Creating your own color and pattern shrimp! Of course, it sounds really cool. Unfortunately, in reality, most of these shrimps will look like a wild version of their species – brown, patchy, strange, and ugly. It takes a lot of time and careful breeding to enhance a particular feature in the shrimp. So, if you are not a professional breeder, I do not see any reason even to try it.
The best you can do is to maintain the quality of your shrimp colony by culling them and adding “fresh blood” once in a while. Otherwise, you risk having traits depression and the shrimplets will turn “wild” color.
11 thoughts on “Culling Shrimp. Selective Breeding.”
Wow Michael, you are a bible, thank you
You are welcome 🙂
Thank you for the review.
I am just getting back into the hobby after a hiatus of 40 years and never bred shrimp.
An example how you bred (and culled) for a specific color or trait would be very helpful.
Hi Austin Raabe,
I am a little bit confused. What kind of example would you like to get?
Do you mean a new shrimp color variation?
Well, I do culling to maintain the current color variation at its best. Although the recommendations (which I wrote in the article) can be applied for bigger projects, it will still take years of hard and dedicated work.
Would you permit me to pass on information to a group of shrimp education
I don’t mind if you leave the link to the original article.
about Put them in boiling water. Painless and quick., it makes Me remember about what I did with My neocaridina breeding project, when I was feel so depressed about what must to do with them (the culls) and I can not release them to the wild river, now I feel relaxed after read your article (at least other do the same as I did and will do). Now is the time for next class, with Caridina crystal shrimp. thank You Michael, especially for that Mendel rules pf inheritance course 🙂
Very informative article; however, I am not sure I agree with you about boiling or freezing the undesirable shrimp. There are plenty of hobbyists who would be more than happy to take them off your hands to act as clean-up crews or as a food supply in their tanks. Circle of life!
Good point! Thank you.
I have made some changes to this list.
Great suggestions Michael. Im really interested to know how quickly my colony will grow assuming average/optimal conditions. I have around 45 in a 50litre tank.
According to the studies, female shrimp can have 20 – 50 eggs. Depending on the temperature the embryonic development of the eggs can last from 25 to 35 days.
It takes baby shrimp about 70 – 80 days to reach maturity.
You can read more about it in my article “Breeding and Life Cycle of Red Cherry shrimp“.
Well, you can do the math 🙂
The short answer is – a lot!